Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590

11:00 am - 3:00 am

The Best Steakhouses in Ithaca, New York

Nestled in the heart of the Finger Lakes region, Ithaca, New York, is not just known for its picturesque landscapes and Ivy League education but also for its vibrant culinary scene. Among the city’s diverse dining options, steakhouses hold a special place, offering both locals and visitors alike a chance to indulge in some of the finest cuts of meat prepared with impeccable skill. Let’s embark on a culinary journey to explore the best steakhouses in Ithaca, New York, where the quality of the steak speaks volumes, and the dining experience leaves a lasting impression.

When searching for a restaurant that serves steak, many steak lovers are left unsatisfied. That is why many individuals interested in wonderfully prepared steak often visit steakhouses or other restaurants focusing on serving quality steak. Restaurant goers in and around the Ithaca, New York area have been visiting the three restaurants below for quality service and amazing steak.

(1) The John Thomas Steakhouse

The John Thomas Steakhouse is located at 1152 Danby Road, otherwise known as Route 96B in Ithaca. The steakhouse is conveniently located near the campus of Ithaca College.

The John Thomas Steakhouse

The John Thomas Steakhouse specializes in steak; however, there are other meal cuisine types available. They also have selections with salads, chicken, and hamburgers. They are open seven days a week. At the John Thomas Steakhouse, you have the option to dine in or take your food home. This establishment accepts all major forms of credit cards, including MasterCard, Visa, and American Express.

Reservations are not necessary at this establishment; however, if you wish to call ahead and schedule one or call for more information, please contact the staff at (607) 273-3464.

(2) The Mahogany Grill

The Mahogany Grill is a restaurant that serves highly recommended steak cuisines, along with other food varieties and is located at 114 North Aurora Street in downtown Ithaca near the Ithaca Commons.

The Mahogany Grill is famous for their Angus Steak and seafood selection. They are open daily for lunch and dinner. The Mahogany Grill does not require reservations; however, you may call and try to schedule one if you wish. They take all major forms of credit cards, including Visa, American Express, MasterCard, Discover Card, and the Diners Club Card.

If you are interested in learning about their dinner selections or checking the meal prices, please contact the Mahogany Grill by calling (607) 272-1438.

(3) Ristorante Banfi

Ristorante Banfi is a fine dining establishment that offers steak cuisine as well as a wide variety of other dishes. Ristorante Banfi is located at 11 East Ave in Ithaca on Cornell University’s campus. The Ristorante Banfi is located in the famous Statler Hotel.

In addition to steaks, this fine dining establishment also serves amazing Italian and American cuisines. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner are all served daily. Salads and appetizers are also available with each meal. All major credit cards are accepted as a form of payment here. These cards include American Express, Discover Card, and Visa. The Ristorante Banfi has personal dining sections and banquet rooms available for special occasions. For fine dining and a wonderful wine selection, please visit the Ristorante Banfi.

To find sample menus or to obtain more information on the Ristorante Banfi, please visit their official website and select the dining option. To schedule a reservation, please contact the staff at (607) 254-2565.

Ithaca’s steakhouses are more than just places to eat; they are culinary destinations that offer an unforgettable dining experience. With their focus on quality, flavor, and sustainability, these restaurants stand out in the vibrant culinary landscape of Ithaca, New York. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor exploring the Finger Lakes region, a meal at one of Ithaca’s top steakhouses is a must.

So, the next time you find yourself in Ithaca, take the opportunity to explore its steakhouse scene. From the ambiance and service to the exquisite cuts of meat and complementary dishes, you’re in for a treat that will delight your senses and leave you with lasting memories. Ithaca’s steakhouses are waiting to welcome you with open arms and a meal that embodies the essence of fine dining. Don’t miss the chance to discover what makes these establishments a cut above the rest in the world of culinary excellence.


Written by


Hi! I'm the Editor in Chief at the CANZ. I oversee all articles published by our writers and even write some of me own! In my free time, I love to try new restaurants, hang with friends and go on walks. I am always down to catch an amazing view of the sun or the stars!